Lump sum or monthly investing?
If you have a sum of money ready to invest, from savings, a bonus or an inheritance, you can invest it all at once or spread it over several months. On average, investing at once ends with more money. Spreading it out mainly buys peace of mind.
Two different situations
The question is often mixed up with a different one. Most people invest from their income: part of every salary goes into savings. In that case there is no lump sum to decide about, and the best plan is simply to invest regularly, starting as early as you can.
The real choice comes up when the money is already there. You can put it all in today (a lump sum), or invest it in equal parts over, say, 12 months. The second approach is called averaging in or dollar-cost averaging.
What the math says
When an investment grows over time, money that is invested earlier has longer to grow. Take 12,000 and a steady 7 % a year over 20 years:
| Approach | After 20 years |
|---|---|
| 12,000 invested at once | 46,436.21 |
| 1,000 a month for the first year | 44,773.69 |
The lump sum ends with 1,662.53 more, because the monthly payments are invested about six months later on average. The difference grows with the time you take to invest: spreading the same money over several years costs much more than spreading it over a few months.
The extreme case shows the principle most clearly. Paying in 48,000 at once and paying in 200 a month for 20 years add up to the same amount, but the results are very different:
| Approach | Paid in | After 20 years |
|---|---|---|
| 48,000 at once | 48,000.00 | 185,744.85 |
| 200 a month for 20 years | 48,000.00 | 101,507.28 |
Compare both in the calculator and see how the gap opens up over the years.
What happens with real markets
Real markets don't rise steadily. If prices fall shortly after you invest a lump sum, you lose more than you would have by spreading it out, and averaging in buys some of the investment at lower prices. If prices rise, the lump sum wins.
Over long periods, stock markets have risen more often than they have fallen, so the lump sum has usually come out ahead. A well-known study by Vanguard (2012) looked at historical returns in the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia. It found that investing a lump sum immediately beat spreading it over 12 months about two thirds of the time. In the remaining third, averaging in did better. A follow-up study (2023) added Canada and Europe, compared shorter schedules of a few months, and came to the same result.
So the trade-off is this: a lump sum has the higher expected result, and averaging in reduces the risk of investing everything just before a fall.
When spreading it out makes sense
- A fall would make you sell. The worst outcome is investing a lump sum, watching it lose 20 % and selling in a panic. If spreading it out helps you stay invested, it is the better plan for you, even if it costs a little on average.
- The sum is large compared with what you have. For an inheritance or the proceeds of a house sale, the regret of bad timing can be hard to live with.
- You are not sure yet. If you are still deciding how to invest, a slow start gives you time to adjust.
If you do spread it out, decide the schedule in advance, keep it short (often 6 to 12 months) and automate it, so you don't end up waiting for the "right moment".
Does the day of the month matter?
For regular investing, it hardly does. 200 a month at 7 % for 20 years grows to 102,081.21 when paid at the start of each month and to 101,507.28 when paid at the end: 573.94 apart after 20 years. Paying in every month, without gaps, matters far more than the date.
Compare paying in at the start and the end of the month in the calculator.
Combining both
Many people do both: they invest the savings they already have and add a fixed amount every month. The calculator's default example is such a plan: 10,000 invested today plus 200 a month at 7 % grows to 140,204.12 after 20 years, of which 58,000.00 is paid in.
Start from this plan and change the inputs to match your own.
Key points
- If you invest from income, invest regularly and start early. There is no lump sum to time.
- With money already available, a lump sum has usually done better than spreading it out.
- Averaging in lowers the risk of bad timing, at a small cost on average.
- The approach you can stick with through a market fall is the right one.